In a post earlier this year (click here) I suggested that there are basically two kinds of photographer: those that go to places to take photographs and those that take photographs of the places they go to. I’ve been thinking a little more about this.
Those of us who’ve spent time in management consultancy have a weakness for 2 by 2 matrices and I wondered if there was a second dimension which might be useful in differentiating photographers.
I reckon there is and that’s the extent to which they post-process their images. At one extreme there are those who do their best to get it right in camera and at the other there are those for whom the image that comes out of the camera is just the beginning.
Put the two together and you get a nice 2 by 2 matrix with each of the 4 quadrants representing a different type of photographer.
I’ve given each of the 4 types a name and suggested some genres of photography which might typically sit in each of the quadrants. Check out the image below.

Documentarians are those who go out with the specific objective of taking photographs of something. It might be birds, insects or buildings. There’s often a considerable investment in time and sometimes in equipment to get the shot that they want.
Observers take their cameras with them when they go somewhere and look for opportunities to take good photographs. They might be on holiday, wandering around a city or watching a game of rugby.
Artists set out to create an image and will typically exercise rather more control over the subject and its environment. Much studio photography would fall into this quadrant and I’d guess that for many of its practitioners as much time is spent at the computer as behind the camera.
Interpreters start with images of things that they’ve seen but do something rather more with them. They may be quite ordinary images to start with but the photographer sees in them the potential to create something rather special.
It’s not quite as simple as that of course. I photographed the mushroom in the featured image above recently. Does that make me a Documentarian? No. I was with my walking group and we saw these amazing mushrooms so of course I photographed them. They were just a part of my day.
And although I don’t do much post-processing I do crop my images, adjust the exposure and colour and occasionally remove something which I wish hadn’t been there in the first place. And I do confess to getting my head around colour grading as a way of get the colours right in my final image.
So I’m pretty firmly in the Observer quadrant.
Does any of this matter? I wonder if it does when it comes to judging photographs.
It seems to me that we tend to talk about good photography as if we’re all trying to do the same thing when quite clearly we’re not. And I wonder to what extent a judge’s own position in the matrix influences his or her assessment of the work of others.
There’s no suggestion that any one quadrant is more worthy than any other. I admire many of the images produced by photographers in the other 3 quadrants but that doesn’t mean that I aspire to produce similar images.
I’m quite happy being an Observer and will continue to do my best to be a better one.
And another confession: although the above is all my thinking I’ve used AI to fine tune it and to produce the table above.



Leave a Reply